The Atlantic Coast Pipeline, and the Fallout

By now everyone knows that the Atlantic Coast Pipeline is dead.

Not everyone knows that there are still issues around the pipeline, ranging from those at the corporate level that none of us will ever likely find out about, to cleanup and remediation of land where excavation was done.

Looming larger than every other issue is the question of who owns the land now that the ACP is gone? It seems like an easy question to answer at first glance. Since the company is gone and won’t be using the land, the landowner should get it back.

It’s not that simple from a legal perspective, though.

You see, all of the paperwork that the Atlantic Coast Pipeline had landowners sign was permanent. The paperwork wasn’t titled “Deed for Real Estate”, but it might as well have been. All the rights that people gave to the pipeline were given forever. The ACP still owns the rights to the land it bought.

When the Atlantic Coast Pipeline quit trying to build a pipeline it didn’t just evaporate away into the ether. The company is still around. Even if something happened to the company, such as bankruptcy or even legal dissolution, it can and will sell the land it owns to another company. Those agreements are valuable and permanent.

Is there anything that a landowner can do?

Well, the Atlantic Coast Pipeline seems to be doing the right thing in respect to landowners and making it so that that land reverts back to them. The company is reaching out to landowners to get them to sign paperwork that gives the ACP time to do remediation work on their land and in exchange they are saying that the property rights will be given back to the landowner. That won’t happen for a number of years yet, but at least it looks like there’s a chance.

I sincerely hope it happens.

It’s not outside the realm of possibility that the Atlantic Coast Pipeline could be revived, though. Some company could come along and buy the paperwork from ACP and start the construction and permitting process back up under a different name. It would be a long, hard project, bit it could happen.

So don’t get your hopes up until the deed is done.

I’m going to toot my own horn now. All of the people who came to me for help with the Atlantic Coast Pipeline were able to negotiate for a clause that said that when the pipeline was no longer in use, the pipeline right of way would revert back to the surface owner who could then remove the pipe if they wanted to. They also got specific language saying that the right of way could only be used for pipeline purposes. No converting it over to some other use, such as a power line right of way.

My clients don’t have to worry about whether they can use their property, or who is going to own it in the future. They know that once the right of way is no longer part of the pipeline, it’s theirs, outright.

The moral to this story is to go find a lawyer who knows the issues you’re facing. When you need an oil and gas attorney, a personal injury attorney just won’t do.

The State of Oil and Gas: October 15, 2021

Natural gas prices are at $5.41/MMBtu, after reaching a high of $6.31/MMBtu. Drilling rigs continue to climb steadily, now at 543, up from 512 on September 17. Gas storage levels have inched up a little closer to the five year average, at 3,369 Bcf. A hard winter will keep natural gas prices high.

A lot of the pipelines listed in this article are being built in the Marcellus/Utica region. That’s good, because we’re pushing the limits of what we can pipeline out of here right now.

Discipline is the word of the day in the oil and gas industry. It’s been imposed by horrible prices during the pandemic, investors realizing that oil and gas isn’t a cash tree, and shareholders demanding fiscal responsibility so they can get returns on their stock holdings. This article argues that this discipline will last.

Pipelines don’t have very good cybersecurity. You might remember that the Colonial Pipeline got hacked back in May, causing gas shortages in the southeast. Turns out the main security issues that pipelines have are the main ones that most humans have. They only use passwords, not 2 Factor Authentication and password managers. If you don’t have these set up for yourself, do it. It’s a little work on the front end, but it makes life a lot easier on the backend and also makes it so that you’re a lot less likely to get hacked.

RBNEnergy analyzes capital spending by oil and gas producing companies. While none of them are planning to make increases to spending before the end of this year, the two that have released figures for next year intend to increase spending next year. That makes a lot of sense. I am just hoping that the increases aren’t out of proportion. Lets stay out of the boom/bust cycle.

Remember when the Biden administration “banned fracking”. Now they are saying they will “restore balance“. This is what I think their end goal was all along. They admit that we can’t get rid of fossil fuels, but want to talk about using federal lands for green energy purposes.

An additional factor slowing down the current drilling “boom” is the cost of services, including both parts and labor.

An article in the Washington Examiner states that oil and gas drillers will start to increase drilling in response to higher oil and gas prices. I mean, that’s just common sense. The question to answer is “when?” We think it’s going to be around the beginning of the year.

This article from the Alaska Journal mentions a point I hadn’t thought about when analyzing the phenomenon of oil and gas prices going up and producers hesitating to drill more. Hedging. All of the producers are hedged at much lower prices than the market price, so they don’t have the motivation to produce more until their hedges run out.

The State of Oil and Gas: September 15, 2021

This edition of the State of Oil and Gas is a few days late. We apologize, with the explanation that we simply couldn’t get to it in time this month.

On September 15, natural gas prices were at $5.46/MMBtu, higher than they have been in seven years. Oil prices were at $72.61, a healthy price. Drilling rigs were at 503, the same level they were last month. They had bounced up to 508 and down to 497. We’d like to see this number going up a little. Storage levels were at 3,006 billion cubic feet, below last year’s level and the five year average.

The financial impact that oil and gas development has on the State of West Virginia is enormous.

West Virginia’s governor activated a dormant agency, the WV Public Energy Authority. This is new on our radar, so we’ll have to watch and see what happens with it.

A natural gas pipeline near Coolidge, Arizona, exploded, killing a dad and daughter, and leaving the mother with burns across half her body. The pipeline was over 50 years old. Based off what I’ve read over the years, it seems that pipelines start having random problems when they get that old. If you have an old pipeline near your house, you should do some investigating into the age, condition, and maintenance of it.

The price of natural gas just keeps going up, and Marcellus shale producers are benefitting.

Forbes has an excellent article about why LNG exports are increasing so much.

The Ohio cracker plant is on an indefinite hold. PTT Chemical is looking for a new partner before making a final investment decision. This is disappointing as an additional cracker plant would provide an additional and added-value use for all the natural gas produced from West Virginia. Anybody out there have a few billion dollars to invest?

Hurricane Ida shut down a lot of oil and natural gas production.

Natural gas production increased in the Marcellus shale area, thanks to new pipeline capacity.

OPEC+ decided to increase production of oil by 400,000 barrels per day, but that didn’t affect markets much.

Producers are moving back to drilling new wells instead of completing DUCs.

There’s a type of compressed natural gas vehicle that I hadn’t heard about, the near-zero emissions (NZE) natural gas vehicle (NGV). How new it is, I don’t know, but if it’s been around for a while it flew under the radar.

I’ve been saying this for years. West Virginia needs to process its natural gas before it gets sent out of state. Turn it into electricity, turn it into petrochemical feedstocks, separate and bottle propane, that kind of thing. It’s good to see someone else thinks so.

A week later, and most of the natural gas production in the Gulf of Mexico is still offline.

Southwestern Energy requested permits to build a well pad within the city limits of Weirton. They were denied. It seems most everybody who showed up at the meeting opposed it. I’ve got no problem with the decision. Well pads are noisy and really light up the night sky during drilling. However, if those issues could be mitigated during the drilling period, a well pad is a quiet unassuming spot afterwards. Seems like the neighbors could get SWN to mitigate sound and light issues. This probably won’t be the last we see of this.

Natural gas prices are up over $5.00/MMBtu and seem likely to stay up there. I would never have predicted that last year. Nobody would have.

LNG demand is likely to keep growing.

US natural gas consumption is likely to decline in 2022, due to the increase in price, according the the EIA. This is exactly why drillers are right to not significantly increase the number of wells they drill. Increase, yes, but not a lot.

The State of Oil and Gas: August 15, 2021

It was kind of a slow news cycle this month. Natural gas prices are down a bit, to $3.84/MMBtu. They had gotten as high as $4.16/MMBtu very recently, but are coming back down, probably on speculation about the new COVID-19 variant making the rounds. Drilling rigs are up to 500, an addition of 26 new rigs this month. That’s still healthy growth, not a signal that we’ll be moving into a boom/bust cycle. DUCs are down to 5,957, a drop of 258. That’s still a lot of DUCs, but they are continually dwindling.

Oil and gas pipelines don’t explode often, but they do explode. This time it was in Kansas, and was in the middle of a pasture, so thankfully it didn’t hurt anybody. They’re currently trying to figure out what made it explode.

The TETCO pipeline transports a lot of natural gas out of our area down to the Gulf Coast. It’s been operating at reduced pressure due to three separate explosions. After providing documentation to PHMSA which supposedly demonstrates that inspections have been done and the pipeline is safe, it is expected to resume normal operations.

Higher oil and gas prices are tempting oil and gas producers to start drilling more. Smaller, private companies are the most likely culprits, as they’ve already almost returned to pre-pandemic levels. We sincerely hope that they’ll continue to exercise restraint, as yo-yoing prices make it hard to run a business.

It’s important to think ahead when you’re signing any kind of agreement with an oil and gas company. The Atlantic Coast Pipeline has been given permission to leave downed trees in place, and leave installed pipeline in place. It’s also unclear whether the easements are going to continue to affect the property. Our clients’ agreements with ACP dealt with all these issues. Most did not.

Fracking is a noisy undertaking. Up in Brooke County, WV, it’s hard to put a well down in an area that’s not close to somebody’s house. The noise is not just bothersome, it keeps people from getting enough quality sleep, as fracking is a 24-hour activity. Whoever is drilling in Brooke County (ahem, SWN) should be more neighborly, but since they didn’t take steps on their own, the County Commission is going to revisit the noise ordinance and do what it can to make sleeping a possibility.

Demand for oil is keeping prices up.

DUCs (Drilled but UnCompleted wells) are dwindling in number, according to this Forbes article. More concerning to us is a quote in that article indicating that virtually all investors are unwilling to give money to oil and gas companies. We’ve been encouraged by the lack of investment capital in the past–forcing drillers to be more efficient–but a complete lack of investment capital will result in a lack of production which will result in a spike in energy prices. The old boom/bust cycle would return, at least for one cycle. That’s not good for anyone.

The EIA is predicting that we’ll enter the winter heating season with below-average natural gas storage levels. That means strong prices for natural gas through the rest of the year, most likely, which translates to good royalties for our clients.

The State of Oil and Gas: July 15, 2021

Natural gas prices are $3.61/MMBtu, which is a healthy price. They got up as high as $3.79/MMBtu. Drilling rigs are at 484, a jump of 23 since last month. With the price of both oil and natural gas going up, it’s likely that this number will rise sharply soon. Natural gas storage levels for July are at 2,629 Bcf, a little under the five year average, and quite a bit under last year’s number.

Whoa! The big news comes right at the top this month! The Biden administration’s moratorium on oil and gas drilling permits has been overruled by a federal judge! Well, “overruled” is a little strong here. An injunction has been issued which delays enforcement of the moratorium until the lawsuit challenging it has wound its way through the courts. That’s a little different from being overturned, but it’s a sign that the lawsuit at least has some merit. You can only get an injunction if there’s some chance that the lawsuit would have success.

Based off headlines found around the news world, one would think that renewables have been making significant progress in producing larger and larger portions of the world’s energy. A recent study shows that’s not the case. In 2009, fossil fuels produced 80.3% of the world’s energy. In 2019 they produced 80.2%. That .01% is a big number, but the proportion is what’s most important.

On the other hand, oil and gas companies have severely cut back their exploration budgets. This could have powerful effects in the near term, such as much higher energy prices and yet another boom in the oil and gas sector. And here I was thinking the boom/bust cycle might be over. Not to put too much stock in an oilprice.com article–I haven’t often agreed with what I read there–but the numbers are hard to argue against.

The rumblings across the oil and gas industry are that supply is not keeping up with demand, which is forcing the price of natural gas up. That’s great news for our clients, as royalty checks should start going up.

Oil prices have also been going up. The rumor is that OPEC+ will start producing more oil. That rumor immediately drove the price of oil down.

The number of frack crews dropped precipitously during the pandemic, but they’re on the rise again. With 235 crews working, we’re just keeping production numbers level.

RBNEnergy does a good review of how wind power is ramping up in the U.S.

Just like that, RBNEnergy puts out another interesting article. This one details how carbon dioxide (you know, the main greenhouse gas) can be used for enhanced recovery of oil (getting more oil out of the ground than usual). You ever hear about carbon sequestration? This is carbon sequestration with an economic purpose.

Well, isn’t this interesting? There’s a pretty long article on Seeking Alpha which makes the argument that we’re in a long bull run on oil and gas stocks. For those who don’t invest, that means that oil and gas companies are a good value, which means that oil and gas prices are likely to stay up because that’s what makes an oil and gas company valuable. My how the times have changed, and quickly, too. That’s the oil and gas industry for you, though.

This is great news for any of our clients who are royalty owners. The price that buyers will pay for gas coming out of our area is going up. So not only is the price of natural gas in general going up, the price that West Virginia producers get is going up, too. That should show up as an increase on the bottom line of your royalty checks!

An “operational event” happened at the Mobley plant in West Virginia, shutting down production from the area. Basically, there’s no natural gas flowing out of West Virginia right now. This will probably affect royalty checks negatively.

A pipeline from a deep water drilling rig in the Gulf of Mexico ruptured and caught fire, resulting in video that looks like something you would see in a movie.

OPEC+ can’t seem to agree on anything right now, which seems to mean that nobody is going to start pumping/selling more oil, which means oil prices are going up.

Natural gas is flowing away from West Virginia again, now that the “operational event” (a leak) was fixed.

OPEC+ has now reached an agreement to increase oil production. This will probably help keep oil prices stable, which will keep prices at the gas pump from rising any higher than they already are.

The State of Oil and Gas: June 15, 2021

Natural gas prices are at $3.25, down off today’s high of $3.35, but up from a low of $2.89 a few weeks ago. It’ll be interesting to see what happens with drilling rigs now that prices are going up. Storage levels are at 2,411 BCF, 55 BCF below the five year average, and right about where they have been compared to the five year average for months. Drilling rigs are at 461, up a little from 453. Slow and steady…..

I ran across an interesting article about some companies building sailing vessels as commercial transport again. It’s an interesting read, just for the subject. It’s also interesting to see that it’s practically impossible to replace modern ships with sailing vessels, if we want to keep our economy.

Jude Clement does a dive into energy use over at Forbes.com and makes an educated guess as to what the future might hold for natural gas and oil.

European utilization of natural gas is also interesting to read up on.

Xiaomi, a cell phone company, has announced that they can charge a cell phone battery in eight minutes. This doesn’t directly affect the oil and gas industry, but it’s a precursor of things to come. The real barrier to switching from fossil fuels to renewables is battery tech, and if fast charging technology like this can be applied to cars, it will change the industry. It’s not time to jump on that train yet. One demonstration device doesn’t mean the tech will make it to cell phones. The fact that it can be done with cell phones doesn’t mean it can be done with cars. But if it can be done with cell phones it most likely will eventually make its way to cars.

Oil and gas companies have exercised restraint in the first quarter of this year, but natural gas prices continue to creep up. Will banks start lending more money to them? It’s still too early to tell.

As natural gas prices go up, energy companies are switching to coal and renewables. Mostly coal. There still aren’t enough renewables to make up the difference.

The large international oil and gas company, Royal Dutch Shell, was ordered to cut carbon emissions by 45% by a Dutch court. While that ruling only applies in the Netherlands, it will be interesting to see what happens in other European courts.

Pew did a poll which showed that 2/3 of Americans don’t want to completely phase out fossil fuels. That 1/3 must be pretty noisy, because I wouldn’t have guessed those numbers. Of course, that’s a poll, and you know how polls are.

This could become worrisome in the future. We currently use about 90% of our natural gas storage capacity. Natural gas demand doesn’t have to grow much for us to hit full capacity. There was some rumbling before COVID last year that we might hit full capacity last year. It bears keeping an eye on.

Pressure on the TETCO pipeline has been reduced. The TETCO pipeline moves a lot of gas from the Marcellus down to the Gulf Coast. This will reduce royalties paid to most West Virginia royalty owners as the price to move the gas through the pipeline will increase, reducing the price that companies can get for the gas.

The price of natural gas is going up, but so is the cost of doing business. Shale drilling requires steel, and steel prices are skyrocketing.

Libya is planning to raise oil output from 1.3 million barrels per day (currently) to 2.1 million barrels per day in the next few years. I’m sure OPEC+ will eventually want to have something to say about that.

The State of Oil and Gas: May 15, 2021

The price of natural gas is $2.97/MMBtu, and the price seems to be going up. Gas storage levels are just under the five year average, pretty much like they have been for the month. Drilling rigs are up to 453, up 21 from last month.

A “groundbreaking” study looked at whether oil and gas wells had the potential for integrity issues (leaking). Using raw data, they determined that 14.1% of oil and gas wells drilled before 2018 had the potential for integrity issues. Testing around wells showed that 3% of wells in Colorado and 0.1% of wells in New Mexico exhibited characteristics that made them susceptible to leakage outside the well. No testing was done to see whether there was actual leakage. They should really follow up with an actual field test for actual leakage instead of just making allegations.

According to the EIA, last winter was warmer than average, until the cold snap in late January and early February, which made up for the rest of the winter. In fact, withdrawals from storage for last winter ended up being 10.6% more than average.

Some landowners who signed easements with the Atlantic Coast Pipeline are now requesting that the FERC force ACP to release those easements. Since the land is no longer needed for the pipeline, that’s a sensible thing to request. I’m going to brag here: our clients don’t have to worry about this issue because we got language in their easements allowing them to request a release once a specific amount of time has passed after cancellation. Of course, if the FERC agrees with the landowners and a release can be acquired sooner, we’ll do that.

Producers are exercising restraint in drilling. I think it’s mostly because they’re having a harder time getting money from banks.

Libya is having budget troubles which may keep them from producing as much oil as they have been.

West Virginia’s Treasurer spoke out against the Biden administration’s push to get banks and lenders to not give money to the oil and gas industry. Honestly, that may not be an awful thing. Banks have historically overlent to the oil and gas industry, leading to boom/bust cycles. A little less money flowing in to the industry should create stability. No money would, of course, be a bad thing.

LNG terminals are running at full capacity.

Oil production from Alaska has been declining since the late 80s. I was generally aware of this, but I wasn’t aware of how much it has declined from its peak. This last decade it’s been pretty flat, which is why it hasn’t made news.

Moody’s predicts a pretty stable oil and gas industry for the next 12-18 months. Predicting stability in oil and gas seems like a reputation destroyer. Moody’s does have a pretty good reputation, though. Guess we’ll see.

Europe won’t get to net-zero carbon without natural gas. Until battery tech advances far enough, renewables aren’t going to replace fossil fuels.

We’re importing less energy, but exporting about as much as we used to.

The semi-truck of the future is self-driving and powered by natural gas. Of course, we all know how “the X of the future” works out most of the time.

Permitting proceeds ahead on a methanol plant in Pleasants County, WV.

The Colonial Pipeline got shut down because it was hacked. UPDATE: It’s back up and running, and the fuel shortage will be alleviated soon.

EQT is just getting bigger. They’ve now bought a bunch of property in Northeast PA.

A liquefaction plant in Jacksonville, FL is going to triple it’s capacity.

The State of Oil and Gas: April 15, 2021

We’re a few days late getting this out. The following number are from April 15, 2021. The price of natural gas is at it’s high, $2.66/MMBtu, having gotten as low as $2.46/MMBtu; the rig count is at 432, up 30 from last month (cool it a bit, drillers); and natural gas in storage is 1,845 Bcf, right back at the five year average. It sure didn’t take long for gas storage levels to come back up to average.

Oil and gas producers are exercising restraint?! So are bankers?!?! This is a sign of the apocalypse.

There’s a bill in the WV House that will require a $2500 fee for modifying oil and gas well permits. This is good. The Office of Oil and Gas needs more money. Hopefully they’ll use it to hire more inspectors. UPDATE: It passed.

Governor Justice proposed eliminating the state income tax. Other sources of income will have to make up for it, and the severance tax (on minerals extracted from the ground) is one of them. You can imagine the oil and gas industry isn’t happy about it, and the coal industry is even less happy about it. As it’s proposed, I don’t see it actually increasing, as it’s a graduated tax, with a 5% tax on anything below $3.00 per MMBtu, and .5% increase on every $0.50 increase in price up to $9.00/MMBtu. The price will never get that high again under current natural gas industry conditions. In fact, it’s unlikely to get up to $4.00/MMBtu for any great length of time. This won’t help the State’s income, and it won’t affect most companies’ bottom line significantly.

One thing that has held up construction of the Mountain Valley Pipeline has been some people sitting in trees on the pipeline right of way. A court ordered them to leave. They stayed. Police brought in a crane and removed them from the trees. Construction will now proceed.

I don’t usually bring up bills that have only been introduced, but this one’s an important one. There are regulatory bottlenecks that hold up LNG exports. This bill would remove those. This is important because the LNG is exported to many developing countries. They need this source of energy. It’s cheap and it’s cleaner than the alternatives. Even environmentalists should be supporting this because the realistic alternative is that if developing countries can’t get LNG they will buy coal and oil for their energy needs, not wind and solar. This bill needs to pass.

Libya is bringing more oil and gas infrastructure online. I wonder how long before OPEC+ starts to impose production cuts on them? They need the cash to rebuild a war torn state, and cutting them back now would just be mean. But Libya will have to join in the cuts eventually.

That horrible forced pooling bill that was proposed this legislative session is apparently dead, thank goodness.

Investors are expecting oil and gas companies to be more disciplined. That’s great news. As long as oil and gas companies could get all the money they wanted, we were always going to experience boom and bust cycles with correspondingly ridiculous fluctuations in energy prices. Discipline will lead to consistency, and this is one business owner really likes the idea of consistent business.

The Suez Canal is back open, and there are about 18 LNG ships waiting to get through. While this doesn’t directly affect U.S. markets, the change in shipping will temporarily change prices.

Pipelines out of Appalachia are running at or near capacity. When that happens, the pipelines raise their prices, in effect reducing the price that producers get for their product. This reduces your royalty check. When the Mountain Valley Pipeline finally gets built, it will help with this problem.

No new LNG projects are expected to be announced this year. At least, there won’t be any final investment decisions (FIDs). There can actually be a lot of money thrown a these high-dollar projects before the final go/no-go decision is made, which is why there are lots of “little” investment decisions, and then a “final” investment decision.

We saw a build in natural gas storage levels. This is earlier in the year than usual, which indicates that producers are aware that we have lower than normal levels of gas in storage and are producing enough gas to make up the difference.

The EIA crunched the numbers and we officially used 7% less energy last year. They are also saying that natural gas prices will average above $3.00/MMBtu during 3Q2021. That would be nice.

The WV Legislature has passed a bill that would change how oil and gas wells are taxed. It will be interesting to see if this increases production and development or not.

The State of Oil and Gas: March 15, 2021

It’s been a month! Natural gas prices are at $2.51/MMBtu, and have fallen from a high of about $3.20/MMBtu over the course of the month. That high was affected by the powerful winter storm in Texas and the Midwest. Rig counts are at 402, up five from last month. That’s a reasonable increase. In fact, that might be a little lower than what we need. Gas in storage (1,793) is below the five year average (1,934), but has crept slightly closer to the average compared to last month.

It looks like EQT is bringing more development to West Virginia. We’ve been seeing more EQT leases in the western part of Marion County, and this article supports our anecdotal evidence that activity is picking up there.

Antero’s quarterly report paints a reasonably rosy picture, with production flat and demand growing. While it would be exciting to see increasing development activity, having flat activity is still good. It means that royalty prices will stay about the same or go up a bit, and there will still be leasing activity.

The Mountain Valley Pipeline has had some slippage issues in Lewis County, WV. It’s a good thing it’s not already in service or there could be some real fireworks.

Mexico hedges its produced oil price using financial tools called options. In the past it has bought options once a year. Now it is going to buy them throughout the year. This should actually reduce some of the volatility of the oil market, just a little.

Oil production is ramping back up.

An article over at Seeking Alpha does the math and makes a pretty strong argument that next winter we’re going to see really low natural gas storage levels. If that’s the case, prices will skyrocket. Keep an eye on rig counts and read the next quarterly reports when they come out.

The extreme cold at the end of February used a lot of natural gas.

The Mountaineer NGL Storage project let a permit lapse last fall. They’ve reapplied. Does that mean that the PTT Global cracker plant is back on? Or does the Mountaineer NGL storage project have another client they’ll store liquids for? We don’t know, but it’ll be interesting to see when the news comes out.

Here’s one opinion stating that it’s unlikely that we’ll see any more interstate pipeline projects like the Atlantic Coast, the Rover, and the Mountain Valley.

The Saudis decided to extend their 1 million barrel per day production cut, which means oil prices will stay high (you saw how gasoline prices went up a bit, right?) and U.S. producers will start ramping up production again.

There’s another forced pooling bill working its way through the West Virginia legislature. It’s a bad bill. It would not give a signing bonus to non-consenting owners, and the royalty is 12.5%. I guess cotenancy wasn’t good enough for the producers, now they are asking for more.

12 Western states are suing the Biden administration over the “fracking ban”, alleging that the administration doesn’t have authority to use “social cost” as a factor in deciding whether to allow fracking on public lands.

The EIA is predicting an increase in demand for energy in 2021 and 2022. I mean, unless there’s another global pandemic or some such, right? Population grows, demand for comfort grows, and energy is needed for those things. So it stands to reason that demand will grow. What will be interesting to see is how much renewable energy grows in the same time span. Interestingly, the EIA said in a different report that natural gas use was down in 2020 except for electric power generation.

The State of Oil and Gas: February 15, 2021

Today is actually February 17, 2021. Somehow the 15th just slipped by without us noticing. Our apologies. Natural gas prices are at $3.23/MMBtu due mostly to the cold weather shutting down infrastructure. We expect prices to slide back under $3.00/MMBtu once Texas and Company get back to business as usual. Rig counts are at 397, up another 24 this month. Gas storage is creeping back down close the the five year average.

Dan Eberhart over at Forbes explains why the Biden presidency will not kill oil and gas production.

And here’s an article about Senator Joe Manchin, Democrat from West Virginia, and how he is going to affect energy policy.

The Brookings Institute published a brief analysis of the problems in Libya and how to stabilize the country. A stable Libya will produce lots of oil. The US would prefer prices low for consumers, but high for producers, so it’s hard to say what would be best economically. Of course, any normal human being will want an end to war, so hopefully the US will work aggressively toward ending this particular conflict.

Of course, there’s the fact that their infrastructure has been neglected during the civil war, so their production is going to be somewhat unpredictable until repairs and maintenance can be completed.

The Mountain Valley Pipeline has hit an unexpected regulatory hurdle. The FERC, the federal agency responsible for approving interstate pipelines, did not approve a necessary permit. The MVP has been moving along reasonably well, without the troubles that the Atlantic Coast Pipeline experienced. The MVP is at least partially complete, too. So not getting approval from FERC at this point may be a hint that there will be more issues in the future.

Michael Boyd at Seeking Alpha published a good article about how the federal land lease permit ban will affect the oil and gas companies working there.

This winter has been average to mild, and so it’s likely that the price of natural gas is going to stay around or below $3.00/MMBtu this year. (This was obviously written before the Big Cold).

We had been hearing for a while that there was plenty of pipeline capacity in the Appalachian Basin. That’s the main reason we weren’t too heartbroken when the Atlantic Coast Pipeline was cancelled. However, the smart folks over at RBNEnergy are saying that production has caught up with pipeline capacity.

The natural gas market is “tightening”, or in other words, supply and demand numbers are getting closer to each other. This means prices are going up.

In spite of the ban on new leases on Federal lands, new leases and permits are being issued.

OPEC+ is fighting about cuts in production, and may require Libya to curtail production.

A lawsuit has been filed alleging that banning oil and gas development on federal lands is actually illegal. They may have a valid argument.

The number of oil and gas well inspectors in West Virginia has always been woefully small. There is a movement afoot to fix that, but funding them is the issue. The solution proposed in this opinion piece of a $100/year/well fee would work fine for horizontally fracked Marcellus or Utica wells, but would make a lot of the old vertical wells unprofitable. In fact, a lot of the old vertical wells are used by regular, everyday West Virginians as a source of gas to heat their homes and water. If operators had to start paying this fee, they would plug the wells (which in itself costs tens of thousands of dollars) or sell them to the surface owners, who would have to pay the fee and get bonded with the state. Somebody has to pay for the well inspectors but this isn’t the best, or even really a good, solution.

Amazon has ordered a bunch of trucks that run on compressed natural gas.

This article about oil prices is titled, “Oil Price: Pundits’ forecasts as good as astrologers’ predictions“. That’s accurate.

One study shows that fracking activity has not led to significant economic improvement in most of the areas where it is taking place. While there hasn’t been an enormous increase in jobs in West Virginia counties, there has been significant money brought in through leases and bonuses, and taxes. Coal had a greater economic effect, as it took more people to mine coal than it takes to drill and produce from wells. The long-term effect was the same, though–as soon as the product was used up, the jobs moved away. West Virginia really needs to lean in to the industrialization side of natural gas or there will be little to show for it when the gas is used up.